Native Community Development Associates (NCDA)

"solution driven services through education, training, and support"

Role of Sovereignty

By

The intersection of tribal sovereignty with law enforcement practices and community relations on reservations is a multifaceted issue with far-reaching implications for tribal communities and the surrounding areas. Tribal sovereignty encompasses the inherent authority of indigenous tribes to govern themselves within the boundaries of their reservations. This authority includes the capacity to establish and uphold its legal frameworks, which can significantly impact the dynamics of law enforcement and community interactions.

To begin with, the sovereignty of tribal communities presents significant challenges in law enforcement and community relations. Jurisdictional complexities among tribal, state, and federal agencies often lead to confusion and inconsistencies, posing obstacles to the effective response to criminal activities within these communities. According to Justo (2023), “Some state and federal courts have been hesitant to recognize the authority of tribal courts, leading to disputes over jurisdiction and enforcement” (Justo, 2023). Limited funding and resources pose significant challenges for tribal agencies, making it difficult for them to enforce law and order effectively. As a result, this can often lead to tensions and strained relationships between the police and the community, which is why maintaining positive relationships with the community is essential, no matter the circumstance.

Tribal sovereignty plays a crucial role in shaping law enforcement practices on reservations by enabling the establishment of autonomous tribal police departments and justice systems. These entities operate independently of state and local authorities, allowing tribes to create laws and procedures tailored to their community’s unique needs and values. Despite these advantages, tribal law enforcement encounters numerous challenges, such as the vast geographic areas they must cover, limited resources, as previously mentioned, and complex jurisdictional issues. According to Whitehurst (2024), “Tribal police and courts are stretched thin and are coping with conflicting jurisdictional issues and underfunding, leaders told the Senate Indian Affairs Committee at a session last month that drew more than 600 comments” (Whitehurst, 2024). The concept of tribal sovereignty empowers indigenous communities and tribal police departments to independently tackle various challenges that align with their unique cultural, social, and political frameworks.

Tribal sovereignty provides tribes with the authority to establish and maintain relationships within their communities, as well as to govern their lands and people. This empowers tribes to make decisions that impact their self-determination. As a result, tribal sovereignty has the potential to create positive outcomes for tribal communities by fostering trust and collaboration between tribal law enforcement and community members, leading to a range of benefits. Justo (2023) emphasizes the importance of tribal police-community relations, stating that they help build a positive relationship between law enforcement and the community, enhancing public safety and promoting trust and respect. Also, when tribal community members witness the justice system within their tribe that is imbued with their own heritage’s cultural values and traditions and is governed by their Indigenous leadership, it can be highly effective in addressing various societal challenges and fostering a sense of community empowerment.

References:

Justo. (2023). Improving Tribal Police Community Relations: Strategies, Challenges, and Solutions. Native Tribe Info. Improving Tribal Police Community Relations: Strategies, Challenges, and Solutions – Native Tribe Info

Whitehurst, L. (2024). How to tackle crime in Indian Country? Empower tribal justice, ex-Justice Department official says. AP News. How to tackle crime in Indian Country? Empower tribal justice, ex-Justice Department official says | AP News

Educational Policies for Native American Children: Bridging Gaps

By

In the state of New Mexico, the educational policies that impact Native American children are of paramount importance in shaping their academic experiences and overall outcomes. There are gaps and inadequacies that must be addressed to enhance the educational environment for Native American children. These gaps may include issues related to funding, access to resources, support services, and culturally relevant curricula tailored to the unique needs of Native American students. According to the New Mexico Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights (2024), “To develop a culturally relevant curriculum, it is necessary for the PED’s Indian Education Department to consult and collaborate with tribal governments and tribal communities in the development of these materials (New Mexico Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, 2024). Addressing these gaps, especially culturally relevant curriculum, is essential to creating a more equitable and inclusive educational system that supports the academic success and well-being of Native American children in New Mexico.

In New Mexico, Native American children lack access to educational resources and curricula that are reflective of their cultural heritage. As a result, educational policies have overlooked the history and traditions of Native American communities, creating a gap between these children’s identities and their academic experiences. This disconnect has significant implications for the learning and development of Native American children in the state. According to Rudiger, Ph.D. (2020), “The 2018 court ruling in Yazzie/Martinez v. State of New Mexico found that “the education system in New Mexico violates the New Mexico Constitution art. XII, § 1” (Decision and Order, 7/20/18, p. 59) and that the state has “not studied or developed effective educational systems for Native American students” (Court’s Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, 12/20/18, ¶3067), despite the directives of New Mexico’s Indian Education Act (22-23A-1 NMSA 1978)” (Rudiger, Ph. D, 2020). In light of this, it is essential to incorporate culturally sensitive teaching methodologies and the integration of Native American viewpoints into the educational curriculum.

Furthermore, the unequal distribution of funding and resources significantly hinders the educational opportunities available to Native American children in New Mexico. This disparity presents substantial obstacles for schools and districts that serve Native American students, including inadequate infrastructure, limited access to educational materials and technology, and a lack of extracurricular opportunities. To address these challenges, developing and implementing educational policies that prioritize the fair and equitable distribution of resources is imperative. This approach is essential to ensure that Native American children access the same high-quality educational resources as their peers, regardless of their background or geographic location. Achieving this goal will necessitate a comprehensive strategy encompassing fair resource allocation, infrastructure enhancement, and promoting extracurricular activities across various districts and schools. Doing so ensures that all students have an equal opportunity to receive a quality education, improve funding for Native American children, and overcome the obstacles present within the education system in New Mexico. Rudiger, Ph.D. (2020) states that school districts with large populations of Native children on federal lands receive federal subsidies known as “Impact Aid” to compensate for the loss of local property taxes. However, the State of New Mexico takes 75% of these funds and redistributes it to other school districts, using federal funds generated by Native students to support the education of non-Native students.

Next, it is imperative to engage in meaningful consultations with tribal leaders, parents, students, and educators to ensure that educational policies and resources are attuned to the unique needs and aspirations of Native American children. Facilitating avenues for community participation is vital for fostering engagement and formulating effective education policies. Providing opportunities for Native American students and parents to address educational issues is essential in mitigating high dropout rates among Native American children. Implementing policy interventions that offer support and strategies to enhance retention rates and academic achievement is crucial. This may involve implementing culturally affirming mentorship programs, academic counseling, and other educational services.

Lastly, to advance the educational prospects for Native American children in New Mexico, it is crucial to adopt an approach that targets the underlying systemic issues in education policies. This multifaceted approach should encompass advocating for culturally relevant education, ensuring appropriate resource allocation, actively engaging with the community, and implementing supportive initiatives. By addressing these critical areas, it establishes a more inclusive, empowering, and supportive educational environment for Native American children in New Mexico.

References:

New Mexico Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. (2024). Educational Adequacy & Disparities for Native American Students in New Mexico. educational-adequacy-for-native-american-students.pdf (usccr.gov)

Ph.D., Rudiger, A. (2020). Pathways to Education Sovereignty: Taking a Stand for Native Children. Tribal Education Alliance. tea-full-report_12-14-20.pdf (unm.edu)

Understanding the Legal Framework: Child Abuse Laws in Indian Country

By

Child abuse is a pervasive and profoundly concerning issue that has far-reaching impacts on communities, and unfortunately, Indian country is no exception. It is crucial to delve into the existing legal protections for children in Indian country and meticulously identify gaps in enforcement and awareness. By comprehensively understanding the intricate legal framework surrounding child abuse laws in Indian country, there can be effective collaboration to enhance the safeguarding of vulnerable children and ensure that those responsible for such heinous acts are held accountable. The legal framework for addressing child abuse in Indian country is notably complex due to the involvement of tribal, state, and federal jurisdictions, which presents unique and multifaceted challenges that require thoughtful and collaborative solutions. In the context of child welfare and protection in Indian Country, a complex jurisdictional landscape exists. Specific laws fall under tribal jurisdiction, while others are governed by federal law. This division can result in gaps and inconsistencies in enforcement, ultimately posing challenges in ensuring that all children in Indian Country receive adequate protection.

The primary aim of examining the laws pertaining to child abuse in Indian Country is to meticulously assess their enforcement and identify any loopholes that may exist. It is equally vital to disseminate information about these laws to ensure that individuals are well-informed about the protective measures for children, especially the Indian Child Welfare Act. According to Fineday (2015), “ICWA was a landmark piece of legislation designed to protect vulnerable children and their families. It places a strong emphasis on keeping Native children within their family bonds, tribe and culture” (Fineday, 2015). The Indian Child Welfare Act is a crucial law designed to safeguard Native American children. It strives to ensure that these children experience positive outcomes and are placed in appropriate environments while maintaining strong connections to their cultural heritage. It is worth noting that many individuals, both within and outside Indian Country, may not possess adequate knowledge about such laws. This lack of awareness can result in the underreporting of child abuse cases and creates significant hurdles in prosecuting those responsible for harming children.

Understanding the legal framework for addressing child abuse in Indian country is important as it fosters collaboration among tribal, state, and federal authorities. Effective collaboration among these entities is vital to ensure seamless communication and cooperation in handling child abuse cases. Enhancing collaboration and coordination strengthens the legal framework but also significantly improves the outcomes for children in Indian country who are affected by abuse. This can lead to better protection, support, and justice for these vulnerable individuals.

In conclusion, it is imperative to thoroughly examine the existing legal frameworks of child abuse in Indian country, given the significant impact it has on the safety and welfare of children. It is crucial to meticulously pinpoint deficiencies in enforcement and awareness and foster collaborative efforts to establish and improve the legal framework that ensures the protection of children in Indian country.

Reference:

Fineday, A. (2015). How the Indian Child Welfare Act Improves Outcomes for Native Families. Asper Institute. How the Indian Child Welfare Act Improves Outcomes for Native Families – The Aspen Institute – The Aspen Institute

Training Child Welfare Professionals in Cultural Competence

By

Training child welfare professionals in cultural competence is essential to ensure that they have the necessary knowledge and skills to engage with and support Native American families effectively. Cultural competence involves understanding the unique cultural backgrounds, values, and traditions of the families they work with. By respecting and valuing these cultural aspects, child welfare professionals can tailor their services to better meet the needs of Native American families, ultimately leading to more effective support and positive outcomes. Another strength of cultural competence, as stated by Virginia Commonwealth University (2019), is that “Cultural competence in social work entails understanding the cultural differences of people in need of social services. Social workers who demonstrate cultural competence strive to understand the cultures of the people they serve and to support them with cultural sensitivity and respect” (Virginia Commonwealth University, 2019).

Native American families have cultural practices and beliefs that significantly impact their engagement with child welfare professionals. Recognizing and honoring these cultural differences is crucial for establishing meaningful connections and trust with Native American families. Comprehensive cultural competence training for child welfare professionals should encompass in-depth education on the historical ramifications of colonization and the systemic barriers that affect Native American families. This training should also provide practical strategies for effectively addressing these complex challenges within the child welfare system. According to the Child Welfare Information Gateway (n.d.), “Understanding the systemic barriers that contribute to the racial and economic disparities in child welfare is essential to dismantling them” (Child Welfare Information Gateway, n.d.).

Cultural competence training is essential for professionals to gain insights into the intricate details of family structure, communication styles, healing methods, and child-rearing practices across diverse cultural backgrounds. By delving deep into these cultural nuances, professionals can adapt their approaches to cater to the unique needs of Native families effectively. Moreover, a comprehensive understanding of the cultural heritage of Native Americans equips child welfare professionals with the knowledge and sensitivity required better to address the specific needs of Native American families. This deeper understanding fosters more adaptive and effective support systems for these communities.

Lastly, to effectively train child welfare professionals in cultural competence, it is crucial to develop detailed and comprehensive training modules that specifically address the challenges impacting Native American communities. These challenges may include, but are not limited to, poverty, lack of access to resources, historical trauma, and cultural differences. The training modules should aim to provide theoretical knowledge and practical skills for professionals to engage effectively with Native American families. Interactive activities, real-life case studies, and opportunities for self-reflection should be incorporated into the training to ensure that professionals can apply the knowledge gained to their work and deeply internalize the information.

References:

Child Welfare Information Gateway. (n.d.). Serving Diverse Families. Serving Diverse Families | Child Welfare Information Gateway

Virginia Commonwealth University. (2019). Why Cultural Competence in Social Work Is a Vital Skill. Cultural Competence in Social Work – a Vital Skill (vcu.edu)

The Co-occurrence of Domestic Violence and Child Maltreatment in Indian Country

By

The co-occurrence of domestic violence and child maltreatment in Indian country is a complex and pressing issue that demands focused attention and comprehensive intervention strategies. Within tribal communities, the intersection of these two forms of abuse presents multifaceted challenges for families and the broader community. Understanding the intricate dynamics between domestic violence and child maltreatment is essential for the development of effective interventions aimed at addressing the needs of both survivors of domestic violence and the affected children.

Domestic violence and child maltreatment are deeply concerning issues that have far-reaching and detrimental effects on individuals, families, and communities. According to the Children’s Bureau Express (2014), “It is well documented that domestic violence and child maltreatment often co-occur in families and that children who are exposed to domestic violence face an increased risk of negative social, developmental, and psychological problems, including juvenile delinquency, decreased social competence, depression, and posttraumatic stress” (Children’s Bureau Express, 2014). In tribal communities, these issues can be further compounded by many factors. For instance, the pervasive nature of poverty, limited access to essential resources such as healthcare and education, systemic barriers that hinder access to justice and support services, and the enduring impact of historical trauma all contribute to the heightened prevalence and complexity of domestic violence and child maltreatment within these communities. The interplay of these factors creates a challenging environment, making it crucial to address these issues comprehensively and sensitively to the unique dynamics in tribal communities.

Developing comprehensive intervention strategies that address both domestic violence and child maltreatment is crucial for fostering positive change in tribal communities. According to the National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges Family Violence Department (n.d.), “A collaborative leadership that includes child protection agencies should conduct a community-level assessment of currently available safety resources for child and adult victims of violence and develop a response plan in four key areas: resources for immediate and long-term safety; resources to provide family stability and basic needs; resources to support accountability and behavior change for batterers; and resources to address the traumatic and long-term impacts of violence for women and children” (National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges Family Violence Department, n.d.). Recognizing the intersection of various forms of abuse, such as physical, emotional, and psychological abuse, is crucial for service providers and advocates to support survivors and their children effectively. By understanding the complex dynamics of abuse, integrated interventions can be developed to address the diverse needs of survivors. These interventions not only aim to break the cycle of violence but also provide comprehensive support, including counseling, access to safe housing, legal assistance, and other resources, to those in need. In addition, The National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges Family Violence Department (n.d.) recommends that child protection services and community-based child welfare agencies should work together with domestic violence organizations and juvenile courts. This collaboration aims to assess the availability of community resources and develop new responses to mitigate the risks associated with the co-occurrence of domestic violence and child maltreatment. Also, it is crucial to employ community-based initiatives tailored to involve members of tribal communities and service providers effectively. These initiatives should be designed to address the specific needs associated with the simultaneous occurrence of domestic violence and child maltreatment within these communities.

In conclusion, it is imperative to adopt a beneficial approach to tackle the prevalence of domestic violence and child maltreatment in Indian country. This approach should prioritize the holistic well-being of survivors and their children. By delving into the complex intersection of these forms of abuse and implementing integrated intervention strategies, tribal communities can actively pursue effective solutions and foster a secure and nurturing environment for families.

References:

Children’s Bureau Express. (2014). The Co-Occurrence of Domestic Violence and Child Maltreatment. The Co-Occurrence of Domestic Violence and Child Maltreatment—July/August 2014 | Vol. 15, No. 7 (hhs.gov)

National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges Family Violence Department. (n.d.) Effective Intervention in Domestic Violence & Child Maltreatment Cases: Guidelines for Policy and Practice. Grn Bk Cvr for PDF (familyjusticecenter.org)

Connect With Us

Native Community Development Associates
P.O. Box 403
New Laguna, NM 87038

P: 505-259-2095
E: melissa@nativecda.org

About Our Logo

Our logo has two feathers that represent the mother and father who I give thanks and praise to, everyday through prayer. The feathers joined at the bottom represent the strength of our mother and father to carry the weight of the world in hopes that we will do what is right and just. The round circle in the logo represents the Earth. The recycle icon in the center of the Earth represents the thought that we should not acquire knowledge and skills only to be kept by our own being, but to share what we have learned with others.